Rabbi Noah Weinberg was visiting the United States of America. He spent one Shabbat in a small New Jersey community. The people were friendly, and because of the small size of the congregation for Rabbi mingled freely with all the congregants. On Shabbat afternoon, when they sat to eat Seudah Shelisheet, the third Shabbat meal, a young man who was sitting next to the Rabbi began a conversation, which expressed his frustration with his ability to learn Torah. The young man described the many hours in the many techniques he had tried in order to grasp the difficult concepts of the Talmud study.
“How come I just can’t get it?” he asked. “No matter what I do, it seems my conclusions are wrong when I get a chance to review with my Rabbi. I am about to give up,” he said he reported.
-Rabbi Raymond Beyda
“Try Try Again”
Commentary on Parashas Terumah
On last Friday’s extra meditation, I posted a video of Rev. LeeAnne Watkins, Rector at St. Marys, St. Paul, a faith community located in the Merriam Park neighborhood of St. Paul, Minnesota. As you may recall, she was lamenting that after “years of experience and lots of good will, traditional Faith Formation programming is floundering in communities across the country,” including her own. In response, the ministerial staff at St Mary’s had stopped offering all adult education classes. They cancelled everything. They gave up. Rev. Watkins gave up.
I just got an email notice from WordPress.com notifying me that the domain name for this blog will expire in 90 days. I can either choose to renew it for another year, or let it lapse, sending my “morning meditations” into obscure oblivion. Believe me, there are times when I’m tempted to give up, too. The contentiousness and extreme lack of unity within the community of faith in Jesus Christ is just stunning at times. It’s not only the lack of unity, but the hostility expressed in our various online exchanges that makes me wonder if there even is a community of faith in the Messiah anymore. Everyone is so concerned with protecting their own turf and their own theologies, usually at the expense of everyone else who calls Jesus “Master” and “Lord.”
An extreme, though understandable, example is found in Lawrence H. Schiffman’s review of Rabbi Shmuley Boteach’s controversial book, Kosher Jesus as posted at JewishJournal.com. Even the concept of attempting to establish peace between Judaism and Christianity is depicted in widely different ways by these two Jewish gentlemen:
Most difficult to accept is Boteach’s claim that Jews should re-accept Jesus as one of their own teachers, so that Jews and Christians will share this common teacher and unite in our service of God. This notion is probably the cause of the great controversy that already surrounds this book. In making this proposal the author ignores two major issues: 1) The symbolism of Jesus in Western culture where Jews were taunted, persecuted and killed in Jesus’ name. It is simply insensitive to expect, as Boteach does, that this experience should be forgotten so quickly. 2) The need for Judaism to draw clear lines between itself and Christianity to avoid losing adherents to the dominant faith. The Jewishness of Jesus is regularly used in evangelizing Jews by Christian proselytizers to ease the way from Judaism to Christianity. So there is no sense to the proposal to reclaim Jesus as a teacher and hero. He is best left to his Christian adherents, even if he was once a fellow Jew who lived by the Jewish tradition.
Although Rabbi Boteach advocates Jews attempting to reintegrate the historical and Jewish Jesus back into Judaism in order to foster Jewish/Christian peace, Professor Schiffman believes that such peace can only be achieved and maintained by abandoning any hope that Jesus could be considered Jewish, relegating him to the exclusive realm of “Gentile god”. While I can certainly understand the need to separate the Christian Jesus from modern Judaism, given the traditional enmity between the two religions, it is still discouraging that Judaism is unable or unwilling to at least consider the teachings of the Jewish teacher from Natzeret, even apart from Christian rhetoric.
Of course, there are plenty of disagreements within Christianity and particularly between the church and the Messianic Jews who have accepted the Nazarene as Master and Messiah, so I don’t have to go looking too far for discouragement. Going back to Rabbi Beyda’s commentary, at the level of the individual, disappointment doesn’t have to be caused by interfaith conflicts. Just facing personal inadequacies can be enough to make you, or rather, to make me want to give up.
But what about our metaphorical Talmud student. Is his case truly hopeless. I found an interesting answer from a very non-religious source:
In this new paper, Moser et al. extends this research by looking at how beliefs about learning shape these mostly involuntary error-related signals in the brain, both of which appear in less than half a second. More specifically, the scientists applied a dichotomy first proposed by Carol Dweck, a psychologist at Stanford. In her influential research, Dweck distinguishes between people with a fixed mindset — they tend to agree with statements such as “You have a certain amount of intelligence and cannot do much to change it” — and those with a growth mindset, who believe that we can get better at almost anything, provided we invest the necessary time and energy. While people with a fixed mindset see mistakes as a dismal failure — a sign that we aren’t talented enough for the task in question — those with a growth mindset see mistakes as an essential precursor of knowledge, the engine of education.
“Whe Do Some People Learn Faster?”
October 4, 2011
I encourage you to read the entire article but in brief, research seems to support the idea that what you tell yourself about learning affects your ability to learn more and to learn faster. If you believe learning is only an effect of your raw, native intelligence, then you internally set limits that you cannot and will not exceed. If, on the other hand, you believe that time and effort can create change and expand your ability to learn beyond your current thresholds, then you indeed will learn more and exceed your limitations.
Interestingly enough, that’s not much different from the advice Rabbi Weinberg gave to the troubled Talmud student.
“That is the worst solution, you could choose” the rabbi responded. “A person has to understand that the learning of Torah is not something that a human being can do without the help of Hashem. Hashem expects you to put in all the effort you can, and then he will produce the results.”
The young man listened and was encouraged. The respect he had for the sage gave him the strength to continue with his suggestion of try try again. Not long after he made a breakthrough. He reached a level where he was able to prepare a portion of the Talmud on his own. Today that young man is a practicing Rabbi in his community teaching others how to learn and how to be patient, if at first they do not succeed.
I’ve presented a lot of content to express what has already been said in a single sentence attributed to 19th century educator Thomas H. Palmer: If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again. W.C. Fields said something similar, but it’s hardly as useful. Then there’s what the brother of the Master said.
Count it all joy, my brothers, when you meet trials of various kinds, for you know that the testing of your faith produces steadfastness. And let steadfastness have its full effect, that you may be perfect and complete, lacking in nothing. –James 1:2-4 (ESV)
Am I trying to give you some sort of pep talk? Not at all. If anything, I’m trying to encourage myself. Given the sad shape the world is in lately, the spiritual struggles of one human being who otherwise is doing fairly well don’t really stack up all that much. To extend that thought back into the realm of famous Hollywood quotes, here’s what the “great sage” Rick (played by Humphrey Bogart) had to say:
I’m no good at being noble, but it doesn’t take much to see that the problems of three little people don’t amount to a hill of beans in this crazy world. Someday you’ll understand that.
If I (or anyone else) feels alone in the world of faith, it’s not because we are separated from God, it’s because we are separated from each other as human beings and disciples of the Master. That separation is largely by choice. We choose to believe this or that about what the Bible says, which makes it difficult for us to associate with people who interpret the Bible differently. We choose to organize a worship service on a particular day, using specific prayers, and songs, and sermons, and others choose to do it differently on a different day. Then we tell ourselves that one type of service “feels at home” while another type “feels uncomfortable,” but those are choices, too.
There’s nothing wrong about making those choices, but having made them, we live with the consequences. I’ve made choices and am living with the consequences now. I can choose to do nothing or choose a different direction and then there will be more and different consequences. Rev. Watkins and the folks at St. Mary’s made a choice and now they, and the people who attend their church, will live with the consequences. If the Talmud student had given up, there would have been consequences too, but he chose to go on and the consequence for perseverance was to become a Rabbi.
We like to think that we make one choice and we never have to revisit it again, but I find that I am looking at the choices I’ve made every day and continually confronting the consequences, adjusting my studies, my searches, my prayers, and my actions all the time as a result. A relationship with God is incredibly dynamic. If I were to dare to become comfortable with my choices, I have no doubt He would challenge me into discomfort, and then I would have to learn something by generating some effort. What we learn isn’t always what we want to learn but it all adds up to something, though I’m not always sure what. In the end, the only thing I know how to do is to move forward, whether I ultimately choose to continue this blog after the next 90 days or not. I can’t see around the next bend on this “trail of faith” which I suppose makes sense. Faith is pursuing the unseen, not the knowable. God is unseen but sometimes, so are people. Even though I know that my goal is holiness and it is God, what the finish line looks like, and whether I’ll accompany anyone else on the journey, is a mystery.
I only know that I can’t give up what I’m doing, whether it is chasing the scorching Sun like Icarus and plummeting to earth in flames, or like the Phoenix, rising painfully from my own burnt and smoldering ashes. I only know that I have to keep trying, regardless of the consequences. Because God will let me do no less.
23 thoughts on “Falling and Rising”
Winston Churchill said it well, “Never give up, Never give up. Never, never, never give up.” This was a great morning meditation because it points out the fact that we struggle with disappointment, especially when God doesn’t act the way we think He should. (of course I’ve never experienced that before–LOL).
If you get a chance take a listen to this week’s interview with Hugh Halter on Steve Brown etc. at http://stevebrownetc.com. I think you’ll be very encouraged.
I’ve been rereading “The Screwtape Letters” which C.S. Lewis said was the hardest book he ever wrote. When talking about our many disagreements and “failures” you might touch on how some of it is instigated from the enemy of our souls. Yes, we’re responsible, yes we blow it all on our own, but we have been warned that we are not the only actors when there is strife and dissent.
I can’t argue that we have an “enemy of our souls,” but in the end, it’s still up to us to continue or to give up. We have been given fair warning (at least if we’ve been reading the Bible regularly) that there is such an enemy and that we can be discouraged by more than natural means. I think that’s part of the “be prepared” messages of the Bible. We need to be prepared, not only for the coming of Messiah, but for what happens to us while we wait.
I’ve been trying to resist posting this video, but what the heck. I love the film “Galaxy Quest” and even as comedy, it provides an important message.
If you want to achieve your ultimate goal as a film critic, shouldn’t that be “two thumbs up?”
Just kidding. Thanks.
“Most difficult to accept is Boteach’s claim that Jews should re-accept Jesus as one of their own teachers, so that Jews and Christians will share this common teacher and unite in our service of God. This notion is probably the cause of the great controversy that already surrounds this book. In making this proposal the author ignores two major issues: 1) The symbolism of Jesus in Western culture where Jews were taunted, persecuted and killed in Jesus’ name. It is simply insensitive to expect, as Boteach does, that this experience should be forgotten so quickly. 2) The need for Judaism to draw clear lines between itself and Christianity to avoid losing adherents to the dominant faith. The Jewishness of Jesus is regularly used in evangelizing Jews by Christian proselytizers to ease the way from Judaism to Christianity. So there is no sense to the proposal to reclaim Jesus as a teacher and hero. He is best left to his Christian adherents, even if he was once a fellow Jew who lived by the Jewish tradition.”
Maybe this should finally lay to rest the zeal of the BE crowd to become a branch of mainstream Judaism…..
Dan, it’s not a matter of Messianic Judaism being recognized as a Judaism by distancing itself from the Master, but being recognized as a valid Judaism, even though faith in Jesus as the Messiah is not shared by the other branches.
“Dan, it’s not a matter of Messianic Judaism being recognized as a Judaism by distancing itself from the Master,”
This is EXACTLY the matter from mainstream Judaism point of view.
There is a different between believing that MJ is a valid Judaism and being accepted as valid Judaism by the other baranches.
And what would be the benefit of MJ doing the opposite and deliberately distancing itself from the rest of its Jewish brothers and sisters, Dan?
And having said that, please keep in mind that this is only one small aspect of the overall theme in today’s “morning meditation”.
“And what would be the benefit of MJ doing the opposite and deliberately distancing itself from the rest of its Jewish brothers and sisters, Dan?”
That was not my point. The willingness to put Judaism as the central tenet instead of Yeshua is.
Galaxy Quest is one of my favorite movies!
” I posted a video of Rev. LeeAnne Watkins, Rector at St. Marys, St. Paul, a faith community located in the Merriam Park neighborhood of St. Paul, Minnesota. As you may recall, she was lamenting that after “years of experience and lots of good will, traditional Faith Formation programming is floundering in communities across the country,” including her own. In response, the ministerial staff at St Mary’s had stopped offering all adult education classes. They cancelled everything. They gave up. Rev. Watkins gave up.”
In todays society parents with children in school, from about fourth grade through high school,have to participate in school life fully if their child to be prepared to go on to higher education(college). In addition to transporting kids to sports practices and competitions, seeing to it that the required for graduation Community Service Requirement is met, there is homework. While we all want our kids to be ‘responsible’ the fact of life is…parents need to know exactly what is going on in each text book, what is necessary to fulfill the requirements of each class. Parents have to participate in School Life…so why is it shocking they cannot attend church related programs.
@Dan: Why does the Jewish worship and the Jewish Messiah have to be mutually exclusive?
@Dree: Mine too.
@Pat: I raised three kids (they’re all young adults now) so I have a pretty good idea of what it takes. It sounds like you’re saying that anyone who is involved in their kids’ lives relative to their eductaion cannot attend church, at least any more than a few hours on Sunday. I’m certainly not minimizing the enormous effort it takes to raise children, but does that mean there’s simply no time for a life of faith?
Other parents, help me out here. Do you find that you have to make a choice between your children and a fully involved life of faith?
“Why does the Jewish worship and the Jewish Messiah have to be mutually exclusive?”
Don’t ask me, James, I am a nice Jewish boy that found his Jewish Messiah.
Don’t ask me, James, I am a nice Jewish boy that found his Jewish Messiah.
Then perhaps so are those who you say have put him aside.
“but does that mean there’s simply no time for a life of faith?”
That is not even close to what I am trying to say. I observe parents, who are trying to be involved in their children’s school life also participating in their religious life, whether Jew or Gentile respectively but feeling very worn out with all the demands put up on them. Once the evening meal is completed fatigue sets in. What constitutes a ‘fully involved life of faith?’
Sorry if I misunderstood your intent, but sometimes a text-only mode of communication isn’t always the best, Pat.
What constitutes a ‘fully involved life of faith?’
Good question. I suppose that varies depending on whatever religious community is involved and how each family defines their “faith experience”.
Since I have already misunderstood you once this evening, is there a solution to this issue as you describe it?
thank you for posting this.
You’re quite welcome.
“Then perhaps so are those who you say have put him aside.”
Oh, you are now suggesting that I also put Him aside? Oh, well…..
That’s not what I said, Dan. I said that if you, a “nice Jewish boy,” can find the Messiah in Yeshua, then maybe so can the so-called “BE crowd”. I don’t think that Jewish people who choose a fully Jewish lifestyle are necessarily putting their lifestyle above the Messiah or above God. After all, the original Jewish disciples didn’t stop living as Jews in order to become members of “the Way”. Why can’t Jewish believers be Jewish, live Jewish, and worship Jewish and still acknowledge Jesus as the Jewish Messiah?
And what lifestyle should the 90% Gentiles, who are in the BE midst should live? Shall they go back to the Churches?
If you’ve been paying attention, I’ve been seriously considering it.